Usually, I’m not much of a political writer. Mostly because there are no right or wrong answers with the issues. It’s an endless debate of trying to prove who’s right, who’s wrong, who’s got the best plan, who’s past is coming back to haunt them, etc, etc. But the new Arizona bill…………well………. that deserves a little bit of my attention. After all, it applies to me and millions of other hard-working legal and illegal immigrants in this country.
First off, let me just explain what the new Arizona bill means. Last Friday, Arizona Governor Jan Brewer signed a new bill that toughens the state’s immigration laws. The law doesn’t take in effect until a few months from now, but it’s got everyone criticizing it; including President Obama. If the U.S. President himself criticizes a new law questioning its legality, that should be the first hint to tell you that something is wrong. Unless it was Bush who was criticizing it haha!! No I’m just kidding with that last joke!!
The bill itself sets a new law in Arizona to “discourage and deter the unlawful entry and presence of aliens and economic activity.” Which basically means that if a person in Arizona looks like a "suspicious illegal immigrant" whether you're on your way to the market, or just out having a good time out with friends and family, an officer can question your status at any given moment. Let's hope everyone remembers their birth certificates and green cards!! (note the sarcasm) For a country that was and still is being built by immigrants, it is a huge slap in the face. And from a state that used to belong to Mexico, well, that’s an even BIGGER slap in the face!
With this new law being set into place, it will “put communities in the crosshairs by requiring state and local government workers to determine if a person is illegally in the U.S. based on a ‘reasonable suspicion.’” Call me stupid but wouldn’t the only “reasonable suspicion” in Arizona be a………gee I don’t know………hmmmm………MEXICAN!! Why don’t they just re-name the bill “Keep the Mexicans Out of AZ!” This undoubtedly will result in racial profiling and discrimination “as it does not prohibit police officers from relying on race or ethnicity in deciding who to investigate.” And with Arizona 3 out of 10 people being Hispanic, I have a feeling the police are going to be quite busy once it takes into effect. Hmmm….I wonder if there will be more job openings for police in AZ soon? Well call me crazy, but I wouldn’t want to work as one anyway since it seems like I’d be hunting down my own people. Oh the betrayal!!
I think back to wonder, what kind of person would support such a law? Oh yea I know!! Someone like my former college dorm roommate who constantly made fun of my ethnicity until I couldn’t take it anymore!! I won’t say her name to prevent being sued with character defamation, but this young lady thought it was funny to say little jokes here and there about me being Mexican. I’m not one for confrontation and I believe ignorance is and will always be around us so I can take a racial punch here or there. However, the first insult was a little prick with a needle to my hand. The second insult was a jab at my family. But the third insult where she called me a “Fuckin’ Mexican” was the last straw. This bitch got a mandatory “Did You Really Just Say That? 101” course with me. My two other college roommates can confirm this battle of words as they watched with excitement. I’d like to think that maybe she learned a little from our argument. The main thing I tried to get through to her is that she has to respect people where they come from. And that she was lucky that I only reacted in an argumentative way. Who knows what would have happened to her if she told those jokes to another Mexican person and acted violently towards her for saying them? For the record, she’s half White and half Irish.
Now it seems a little obvious that maybe the “intelligent” Jan Brewer didn’t really think this bill through because of the major financial burden it will cost Arizona (notice the sarcasm here). According to an article I just read on reuters.com, “The costs to arrest, detain, process, and transport undocumented immigrants out of Arizona will drain local government treasuries. There were an estimated 460,000 undocumented immigrants in Arizona as of January 2009, making up to 4 percent of the state’s population. If the federal government were to handle the entire undocumented population, the cost would be approximately $23,148 per person, based on a recent study by the Center for American Progress.” Also, “Local taxpayers will bear the heavy costs of lengthy court litigation.”
With police focusing on who is legal or illegal in a state where 3 out of 10 people are “illegal-looking” ooops! I mean Mexicans, the responsibility of police is going to be greatly affected. “The Arizona Association of Chiefs of Police firmly opposes the law for fiscal and public safety reasons, noting that fear of government will diminish the public’s willingness to cooperate with police in criminal investigations and will ‘negatively affect the ability of law enforcement agencies across the state to fulfill their many responsibilities in a timely manner.’” If even the Chief of Police in Arizona is against it (even though it’s for fiscal and public safety reasons), then how in the hell does this ignorant Governor think that she can get away with this?!!
I understand that the law is to keep ALL illegal immigrants out under “reasonable suspicion” (i.e. Mexican looking), but are they really going to question a Canadian person from Canada who could be in Arizona illegally? Are they going to question a Jamaican from Jamaica? How about a Japanese person from Japan who somehow got to Arizona illegally? No!! All they will do is look at the brown color of their skin as they walk to the store or as they play at the park with their kids and demand to know their status.
It’s sad to say but this kind of reminds me of The Holocaust. Jan Brewer will be Hitler, the police will be the Nazis, The Mexicans (or all illegal immigrants) will be the Jewish victims, and the prisons will be the concentration camps sans genocide.
The fact that Congress hasn’t been able to ratify an inclusive immigration reform that restores border security could be the reason why this Arizona bill came to be. However, it is not the answer. It is ignorance, racism, and discrimination at its finest. It denies rights guaranteed in the U.S. Constitution. "It violates the civil and human rights of the Latino community. It goes against all human dignity, against the principles of most Americans I know" - Shakira. And excuse me for my foul language, but it’s un-fucking-believable. I apologize if I offend anyone. Thank you for reading.
sources:
http://www.americanprogress.org/
http://www.reuters.com/
http://www.yahoo.com/
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
6 comments:
HIIIII nina!!! i really like this one. It is very informative. :)
-your #1 fan
Flaws in your arguement
1.Why is it betrayal to work for immigration? Enforcing laws makes one a traitor?
2.You say Arizona was once part of Mexico so that Mexicans ahve a right to be there.There are 21 indegegous tribes that have been in Arizona long before Mexicans, so if anyone can lay a historical claim it is them. BTW would you live in AZ if it was part of Mexico, have you been to Tijuana?
3. The whole purpose of the bill is to target illegal immigrants, not a specific groups. People from Italy, Ireland and other European countries are in the nation illegally. They are deported but get now sympathy because they are white.
4. Maybe the governor know it wont hold up but it is a way to bring attention to the border problem. Do you want open borders? Or let anyone in? If that is true look at history, any nation that could not control who came in and out of their borders fell, Rome being the best example.
5. Your PC attitude makes me laugh. You say undocumented instead of illegal because you dont want to call them what they are. If i break your window and come into your apartment without your permission, am I in your house illegally or undocumented? Has anyone one called the police for an undocumented entry into their home or business?
6. Chief of Police has to do what the law and governor say, unless it is knowingly illegal, if not they should be removed.
7. You say they will only ask brown skinned people. The truth is they will ask anyone with an accent, regardless of skin color.
8. Holocaust, they are being killed? They are having stars put on their clothes, not allowed to go to movies or swimming pools? The Jews had the right to be in those countries because they were there legally and were citizens.
I do not agree with the way the law is written but I agree with its spirit. I am a consitutionalist so it does violate the 4th amendment. However I am for a law that states "when ANYONE is arrested or written a citation they will be subject to a residency check".
I know you will be against this.
I cant wait for your reply.
Erik
Yes! You've inspired me to do my blog for Monday about this. I will offer a different angle. Stay tuned. I will step out of my techy blog and let it rip. Both ways watch out
This is the 1st time since the invention of BLOGING that I read a Blog that's no kidding. I really liked it Chenita : ) you took the words out of my mouth most of the time in your blog. I have always said that we cannot get through people who are ignorant porke (excuse my lingo) estan eNDEJOS! (u put the 'p'). By the way, I have never ever been discriminated at least not that I can remember; till' I moved to the south. MOst people here are sweet as can be. However I have met so many race haters. If you are not white you are ILLEGAL and it's worst if you're hispanic, how sad is that : (
Wow! I do not like that dude erik. but i did like your article and the way you relate and freely express your thoughts on the issue. thans for posting. i may not be completely for it, but def against it and agree that this is not the answer. good job chena.
hello, erik. I find your "comment" very offending. Were you stating your opinion or were you criticizing. I say you were criticizing. If you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at ALL. You are an insensative jerk and I can't believe you talk to such a sweet, loving person like Jesenia. YOU DON'T DESERVE TO TALK TO HER! You do not know how to appreciate good writing. If you are just going to criticize her blog, then why the f*** do you read it!
Post a Comment